History of Mother’s Day

The city of Philadelphia. Philadelphia is the largest city in Pennsylvania. A person may ask the question, “What’s so special about Philadelphia?” Movie buffs may quickly hum or sing a particular movie’s theme song or recite a slogan, “Yo Adrian,” or described the famous running scene from the movie Rocky. Hip Hop enthusiast know it’s the home of the first hip hop group to win a Grammy, which is DJ Jazzy Jeff & The Fresh Prince. Patriotism know it’s the home of the Liberty Bell along with the Independence Hall where The Declaration of Independence and the Constitution of the United States were signed. However, many may not know, except Historians, it’s the home of Anna Jarvis the woman who began a tradition which has come to be known as Mother’s Day.

May 12, 1907 (Encyclopedia Britannica, 2014) is the origin date given where Anna Jarvis held a memorial services for her late mother. In 1914 it became a national holiday by President Woodrow Wilson. Traditionally, a white carnation was attribute to one’s mother. Over the years a red or pink carnation is used to represent a living mother, while a white carnation identifies a mother that is deceased. In addition, over the years, Mother’s day included paying tribute to aunts and grandmothers or any maternal figure.

In the year 2016, Mother’s Day falls on Sunday, May 8. Mother’s Day is a day that is observed in the United States and other countries. It is a day that is special for the work and contribution that mothers do. The majority is unaware of what a mother has to sacrifice or go through for the sake of their child. Which brings up the argument of birth mothers and adopted mothers. Do birth mothers, who gave their child up for adopted, worthy of recognition of Mother’s Day? Do adopted mothers, who took in a child that is not biologically theirs, worthy of recognition of Mother’s Day? Birth mothers who gave up their child and adopted mothers both may experience core issues related to adoption (Timm, Mooradian, & Hock, 2011)  such as loss & grief, entitlement, claiming, family integration, bonding and attachment, identity, and mastery and control.

Loss& Grief

A loss is the process of losing something and grief is a deep sorrow. A birth mother may experience tremendous loss and grief of giving away something that grew inside of her. It is loss that the birth mother will not raise the child in their own home or provide for them. Adopted mothers may experience loss and grief that they are unable to have their own biological child and experience natural motherhood.

Entitlement

Entitlement, is related to having the “right” to certain things. A birth mother no longer have the legal rights to her child because she legally gave those rights them up. However, she still remains the biological mother, which is a right in its own. Adopted mothers at times may struggle with do they have the right to discipline or put the child in certain activities or care for the child in a particular manner since the child is not biologically theirs. 

Claiming/Un-claiming

Claiming, (Timm et al, 2011, p 274) “is the process by which adopted parents accepted the adopted child (ren) as their own, consider them to be full-fledge members of the family, and begin to identify similarities between the child (ren) and themselves, or other family members.” Un-claiming is process by which the birth mother has to consider their child not be full fledged members of another family and for that child to identify themselves with that family.

Family Integration/Separation

Integrating a child into a new family has its struggles. A single adopted mother now has to integration of child into her single life and the arrangement that needs to be made. An establish family, the mother has to integrate a “new child” into the everyday functions of the family. The birth mother goes through separation of what life with the child could have been and how her life would have different.

Bonding& Attachment

Adopted mothers may experience challenges with bonding and attachment of the new child that is not biologically theirs. A child is displaying behavior or likes that are not that them or their significant others. Birth mothers may experience an empty bond. Intellectually know they have a child, however no emotional bond with that child.

Identity

Adopted mothers may struggle with the identity of being a “real” mother because the child is not biologically theirs. Social stigma may play a role in the adopted mothers struggle. Also for the birth mother may struggle with identity of not being a mother because of the fact she gave her child up. Social stigma as well may play a part in what her identify should or should not be.

Mastery& Control

Adopted mother and birth mothers may experience a lack of master and control over the thoughts or emotions that comes from the whole process of giving their child up for adoption or accepting a child from adoption. Many thoughts and emotions may come a one time or little by little, nevertheless, managing one’s self is challenge in its own right.

Summary

Are birth mothers, who gave their child up for adoption, worthy of recognition of Mother’s Day? Are adopted mothers, who took in a child that is not biologically theirs, worthy of recognition of Mother’s Day? The answer is yes. A birth mother who gave her child up for adoption, definitely gets recognition for her role having given birth to a child, unselfishly given up the child, and her own personal experience with core issues of adoption. An adoption mother who decided to take on a mother’s role with a child who biologically is not theirs, a stranger, with outcomes based on genes unknown, along with her own personal core issues challenges, is very worthy of recognition on mothers’ day as well.

References:

Mother’s Day. (2014). Encyclopedia Britannica.  

Timm, T.M., Mooradian, J.K., & Hock, R.M. (2011). Exploring core issues in adoption: Individual and martial experiences of adopted mothers.