In the news…
On March 28, 2016, (Khan, 2016) Noraidah Mohd Yussof pleaded guilty to two counts of assaults which lead to serious injuries and death to her son. This is not Noraidah Mohd Yussof's first time involved in the legal system due to injury of a child. In March of 2012, (Khan, 2016) Noraidah Mohd Yussof became angry when her son was unable to recite the alphabets. She was so angry that she pushed him, stepped on his ribs, and twisted and pulled his hands. Days later she took him to the hospital where he was diagnosis with having fractures to his elbow and his ribs. The son was removed from the home and placed with family members due to the intervention of The Ministry of Family and Social Development.
In August 2015, (Khan, 2016) Noraidah Mohd Yussof picked up her son from school and after lunch asked him to recite his numbers in English and Malay where he recited them incorrectly from 11 to 18. She pushed him resulting in him hitting his head. He attempted to recite them again correctly and failed, resulted in her pushing him and stepping on him. A third attempt, he got them wrong, resulted in her choking and pushing him against the wall where he passed out. She lied to her family members that she found him in the bathroom unresponsive. The child underwent emergency surgery where he died four days later; he was only 4 years old.
Parenting at Risk
Parenting at Risk is a term that identifies a person who has a child who is in risk of faulty parenting due to parental depression, poverty, adolescent motherhood, parental substance and alcohol abuse, and maltreating parents (Teti & Cole, 2011). Studies have been conducted where “emotionally positive parents are happier, more socially competent, and have lower rates of behavior problems than do children of parents with low levels of expressed positive and/or high level of negative emotion, and that such linkages transcend race, ethnicity, and socioeconomic status (Teti & Cole, 2011, p. 627). However there have not been many studies conducted on parent’s emotions in action of parenting referred to as “parenting in the moment (Teti & Cole, 2011, p. 628).”
Child Oriented vs. Parent Oriented
A parent may have very good self-regulation of their emotions, generally speaking. However, when a child engages in behavior and the parent is engaged with that child (parenting in the moment) that parent may not be as competent in self-regulating their emotions as previously stated. The reason is based on the parent’s orientation. Is the parent, child-oriented or parent-oriented?
Child-Oriented (Teti & Cole, 2011) is when the parent’s concern is that of the child and the behavior of the child is innocent. Parent-Oriented (Teti & Cole, 2011) is when the parent’s concern is of themselves, the parent, and the child’s behavior is more looked at as intentionally disrespect or disobeying the parent. An example is that a parent walks into the kitchen, and their child spilled a gallon on milk all over the floor. The child-orientated parent looks at that situation as the child not having the skill to manage the heavy gallon and milk, and clean up begins. The parent-oriented parent looks at the situation as the child deliberately dropped the gallon of milk to mess up the floor the parent spent a good amount of time cleaning yesterday. This parent may be more incline to use physical punishment verses discipline with the child.
In the case with Noraidah Mohd Yussof, her child’s behavior when unable to recite his alphabets and numbers in English and Malay correctly from a child-oriented concern, it may have resulted in her assisting him in developing that memorization skill or learning new strategies to recite the numbers correctly. By her looking at the child’s behavior from a parent-oriented concern, the child intentionally failed to recite them correctly and wasted her time that she spent with him learning them correctly. From a parent-oriented concern, the child is to be punished. The degree to which Noraidah Mohd Yussof used punishment as a reinforcement to learn was inappropriate, maladaptive, and abusive. It is very healthy for a parent to be aware that they are unable to control their emotions while parenting and seek assistance to develop better parenting skills.
References
Khan, S. (2016) Woman kills four-year-old sonby choking and stomping on him. Yahoo news. Retrieved from https://www.yahoo.com/news/mum-pleaded-guilty-to-causing-grievous-hurt-082106137.html?partner=CHEETAH.
Mence, M., Hawes, D.J., Wedgewood, L. Morgan, S., Barnett, B., & Kohloff, J. (2011). Emotional flooding and hostile discipline in the families of toddlers with disruptive behavior problems. Journal of Family Psychology, Vol. 28 (1), 12 – 21.
Teti, D. M. & Cole, P.M. (2011). Parenting at risk: New perspectives, new approaches. Journal of Family Psychology. Vol. 25. (5), Oct, 2011 pp. 625-634.